Charity Service Pilots: 4 Stage-gate Decisions for Real Impact & Less Stress

Ever had a brilliant idea for a new charity service, only to see the pilot stumble or, worse, get rubber-stamped as "permanent" before anyone truly checked if it worked in the field?

We've all been there. That's where "stage-gates" come in.

Think of them as simple, honest checkpoints.

They transform hope into smart, evidence-backed decisions: keep going, grow bigger, hit pause, or stop gracefully.

This is all part of a solid service lifecycle. From discovering a need to designing a solution, delivering it, and eventually retiring it, stage-gates help your charity connect big-picture strategy with daily impact.

Here are the four crucial stage-gate decisions and the down-to-earth rules to make them stick.

Four essential stage gates for charity service pilots

Gate 1: Go

(Is this pilot actually worth starting?)

• Ask yourself: Do we have a crystal-clear problem we're trying to solve, and a straightforward idea we can actually test?

• You'll need: Just one or two main ways to measure if it's working (what does "success" really look like?), a clear timeframe, and crucial input from people with lived experience. If you can't pinpoint what success means in the next 8–12 weeks, hold fire.

Remember the golden rule of "Design & Test": start small, not perfect.

Gate 2: Grow

(is it time to roll this out wider?)

• Ask yourself: Are the results consistently good, safe for everyone involved, genuinely affordable, and fair for all?

• You'll need: Solid proof of who you're reaching, the impact you're making, and any fairness gaps. Plus, get a realistic estimate of resources and a clear plan for how other teams will take this on without a hitch. If scaling creates new risks or piles hidden work onto other teams, hit pause and refine your model.

Top tip: make "will this break anything else?" a mandatory question on your checklist!

Gate 3: Pause

(Is there more to learn before we commit?)

• Ask yourself: Are the results a bit mixed, or has something in our world shifted since we started?

• You'll need: A quick, focused "learning sprint" (think 30, 60, or 90 days max!), a clear point person for that sprint, and a laser-focus on the exact questions you need answers to.

Remember, pausing isn't admitting defeat. It's smart, disciplined learning in action.

Gate 4: Stop

(Is it time to close the pilot?)

• Ask yourself: Is this pilot simply not delivering what we hoped, it is unfair to some people, or no longer a good fit with our charity’s mission?

• You'll need: A thoughtful transition plan for everyone using the service, a note on how you’ll manage any risks, and a concise report for the board/exec explaining the evidence and what happens next.

Closing a pilot down properly isn't a failure; it's responsible stewardship of your charity's resources and mission.

Making these four stage gates work for your charity service pilot: Your quick checklist

✅ Who's in charge?

Clearly name the decision-maker (likely your service owner or a key pair).

✅What does success look like?

Agree on just 1–2 key metrics before you start, and know exactly how you’ll gather that data.

✅Time's up!

Set a firm deadline for each gate, and commit to it.

✅Bring in lived experience

Always include real voices at each checkpoint. They're brilliant at spotting unexpected issues or hidden harms.

✅Keep it clear

Document every decision and why it was made in plain English that funders and frontline staff can easily understand.

Next steps

Stage-gates aren’t here to make decisions for you. They’re here to empower better, more honest choices, backed by evidence, real-world impact, and genuine care.

So, grab one pilot, give its owner a super-simple one-page brief, and let these four gates be the backbone for truly honest choices about what to scale, what to learn from, and what to let go of gracefully.

If you're keen for the complete lifecycle playbook and all the templates, you'll find them in our longer guide on service lifecycle management.

Change truly starts with one honest conversation – why not make your next pilot the place it happens?

Let's Chat

Note: Examples are for illustrative purposes only; no official affiliation with the organisations or tools mentioned is claimed. AI systems can be unpredictable, so always keep personal or sensitive data out of third-party tools and ensure your implementation follows your own organisation’s data protection policies.